Women Victims and the Criminal Justice System: A Comparative Analysis Between Common Law and Civil Law Countries

Publication Information

Journal Title: Journal of Legal Studies & Research
Author(s): Mansi Jain
Published On: 14/02/2023
Volume: 9
Issue: 1
First Page: 136
Last Page: 158
ISSN: 2455-2437
Publisher: The Law Brigade Publisher

DOI Not Allotted [Get DOI]

Cite this Article

Mansi Jain, Women Victims and the Criminal Justice System: A Comparative Analysis Between Common Law and Civil Law Countries, Volume 9 Issue 1, Journal of Legal Studies & Research, 136-158, Published on 14/02/2023, Available at https://jlsr.thelawbrigade.com/article/women-victims-and-the-criminal-justice-system-a-comparative-analysis-between-common-law-and-civil-law-countries/

Abstract

The laws on rape, domestic violence, and sexual assault have undergone major reforms in various common law and civil law countries, to the extent that the focus is being laid upon under-reporting of offences taking place against women and high rate of attrition in the criminal justice system, by emphasising on the necessity to avoid negative and prejudicial attitudes of the police, prosecutors, jurors, and judges towards the women victims. The unsympathetic attitudes of the criminal justice system led to victimisation of the victim and represents the bias existing in the criminal justice response towards the victims of sexual assault, rape, and domestic violence. Decades, after these law reforms, there is ample evidence to prove that victimisation of women victims happen at a high rate in the criminal justice system. The paper aims to present a comparative study and critical analysis of the criminal justice system responses in the United States, United Kingdom, France and India and other common law and civil law countries towards such victims from the perspective of police, prosecutors, jurors and judges and society per se. The paper argues that continued victimisation and prejudicial attitudes of the criminal justice system exaggerates the trauma suffered by these victims and results in less convictions of the accused, exonerating violent men.

Keywords: Criminal Procedural Law, Comparative Criminal Procedure, Common Law, Civil Law, Women Victims of Crime, Criminal Justice System

Share this research

Latest Publications

Journal of Legal Studies & Research
Scroll to Top