The Fair Use Doctrine and its Consequences in Light of The United States Constitution, The Three-Step Tests Provided in The Berne Convention and The Trips Agreement

Publication Information

Journal Title: Journal of Legal Studies & Research
Author(s): Avtandil Sofromadze
Published On: 15/03/2023
Volume: 9
Issue: 2
First Page: 47
Last Page: 55
ISSN: 2455-2437
Publisher: The Law Brigade Publisher

DOI Not Allotted [Get DOI]

Cite this Article

Avtandil Sofromadze, The Fair Use Doctrine and its Consequences in Light of The United States Constitution, The Three-Step Tests Provided in The Berne Convention and The Trips Agreement, Volume 9 Issue 2, Journal of Legal Studies & Research, 47-55, Published on 15/03/2023, Available at https://jlsr.thelawbrigade.com/article/the-fair-use-doctrine-and-its-consequences-in-light-of-the-united-states-constitution-the-three-step-tests-provided-in-the-berne-convention-and-the-trips-agreement/

Abstract

The primary objective of copyright law is to furnish the public with intellectual and artistic creations. To secure the benefit of creative works for the public and incentivize future creation, copyright protection provides authors with limited monopoly rights over their creations.[i] The fair use doctrine[ii] plays a crucial role in the copyright mechanism as it enhances access to copyrighted works and constrains the scope of copyright protection. However, the fair use doctrine has been the subject of debate and controversy, it has been heavily criticized due to its vague and broad nature. I respectfully disagree and, in this discussion, I will examine the fair use doctrine and its consequences in light of the United States Constitution’s ‘IP clause’ (Section 1.8.8), the three-step tests provided in the Berne Convention[iii], and the TRIPS Agreement[iv].

[i] Lauren Gorab, A Fair Use to Remember: Restoring Application of the Fair Use Doctrine to Strengthen Copyright Law and Disarm Abusive Copyright Litigation, 87 Fordham L. Rev. 703 (2018), pg. 706.

[ii] In the United States, fair use often is said to have originated with Justice Joseph Storyโ€™s opinion in Folsom v. Marsh, 9 F. Cas. 342 (C.C.D. Mass. 1841), although intimations of fair use can be discerned in opinions before Storyโ€™s and in earlier English case law.

[iii] Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, September 9, 1886.

[iv] The Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, 1994.

Keywords: The Fair Use Doctrine, The United States Constitution, The Three-Step Tests, The Berne Convention, The TRIPS Agreement.

Share this research

Latest Publications

Journal of Legal Studies & Research
Scroll to Top